HOME
ListMoto - Benjamin Tucker


--- Advertisement ---



(i) (i) (i) (i)

Benjamin Ricketson Tucker (/ˈtʌkər/; April 17, 1854 – June 22, 1939) was a 19th century proponent of American individualist anarchism, which he called "unterrified Jeffersonianism,"[4] and editor and publisher of the individualist anarchist periodical Liberty.

Contents

1 Early life and influences 2 Anarchism

2.1 Liberty
Liberty
(1881–1908)

3 The Four Monopolies

3.1 Land monopoly 3.2 Money and banking monopoly 3.3 Tariffs and patents 3.4 Yarros on Tucker 3.5 Attitude towards unions 3.6 Anarchist society

4 Private defense forces 5 Embrace of "egoism" 6 Later life 7 In popular culture 8 References 9 Further reading 10 External links

Early life and influences[edit]

Benjamin Tucker
Benjamin Tucker
at a young age

Tucker made his editorial debut in libertarian circles in 1876, when Heywood published Tucker's English translation of Pierre-Joseph Proudhon's classic work What is Property?. In 1877, Tucker published his first original journal, Radical Review, which ran for only four issues. From August 1881 to April 1908, he published the periodical, Liberty, "widely considered to be the finest individualist-anarchist periodical ever issued in the English language".[5] In 1892, he moved the Liberty
Liberty
from Boston to New York. Anarchism[edit]

Part of the Politics series on

Anarchism

Schools of thought

Black Capitalist Christian Collectivist Communist Egoist Existentialist Feminist Green Individualist Insurrectionary Leftist Left-wing market Magonist Mutualist Naturist Pacifist Philosophical Platformist Post-anarchist Post-colonial Post-left Primitivist Queer Social Syndicalist Synthesist Vegan Without adjectives

Theory Practice

Anarchy Anarchist Black Cross Anationalism Anti-authoritarianism Anti-militarism Affinity group Black bloc Classless society Class struggle Communes Consensus democracy Conscientious objector Counter-economics Decentralization Deep ecology Direct action Direct democracy Dual power Especifismo Expropriative anarchism Free association Free love Free school Freethought Horizontalidad Illegalism Individualism Individual reclamation Isocracy Law Mutual aid Participatory politics Permanent autonomous zone Prefigurative politics Proletarian internationalism Propaganda of the deed Refusal of work Revolution Rewilding Self-ownership Social center Social ecology Social insertion Somatherapy Spontaneous order Squatting Temporary Autonomous Zone Union of egoists

People

Émile Armand Mikhail Bakunin Alexander Berkman Alfredo M. Bonanno Murray Bookchin Noam Chomsky Buenaventura Durruti Sébastien Faure David D. Friedman Mahatma Gandhi William Godwin Emma Goldman Francesc Ferrer i Guàrdia Peter Kropotkin Gustav Landauer Ricardo Flores Magón Nestor Makhno Errico Malatesta Louise Michel Johann Most Rudolf Rocker Murray Rothbard Pierre-Joseph Proudhon Diego Abad de Santillán Lysander Spooner Max Stirner Henry David Thoreau Leo Tolstoy Benjamin Tucker Volin Colin Ward Josiah Warren John Zerzan

Issues

Anarcho-capitalism Crypto-anarchism Animal rights Capitalism Education Criticisms Islam Lifestylism Marxism Nationalism Orthodox Judaism Religion Love and sex Violence

History

Paris Commune Cantonal Revolution Hague Congress International Conference of Rome Trial of the Thirty Haymarket affair May Day Anarchist Exclusion Act Congress of Amsterdam Tragic Week High Treason Incident Manifesto of the Sixteen Individualist anarchism
Individualist anarchism
in the United States 1919 United States
United States
bombings Biennio Rosso German Revolution
Revolution
of 1918–19 Bavarian Council Republic Kronstadt rebellion Third Russian Revolution Free Territory Amakasu Incident Escuela Moderna

Individualist anarchism
Individualist anarchism
in Europe (in France)

Spanish Revolution Barcelona May Days Red inverted triangle Labadie Collection May 1968 Provo LIP Kate Sharpley Library Australian Anarchist Centenary Carnival Against Capital 1999 Seattle WTO protests Occupy movement

Culture

Films Anarchist Bookfair Anarcho-punk Arts Culture jamming DIY culture Freeganism Hip hop Independent Media Center Infoshop The Internationale Jewish anarchism "Land and liberty" Lifestylism "No gods, no masters" Popular education "Property is theft!" Radical cheerleading Radical environmentalism Red and Anarchist Skinheads Squatting Symbolism Glossary A las Barricadas

Economics

Communization Co-operatives Cost the limit of price Economic democracy Economic secession Gift economy Give-away shop Market abolitionism Mass strike Mutual aid Participatory economics Really Really Free Market Socialization Wage slavery Workers' self-management

By region

Africa Argentina Australia Azerbaijan Bolivia Brazil Canada China Cuba Ecuador Egypt France French Guiana Germany Greece India Iceland Ireland Israel Italy Japan Korea Mexico Monaco New Zealand Poland Puerto Rico Romania Russia Singapore South Africa Spain Sweden Transnistria Turkey Ukraine United Kingdom United States Venezuela Vietnam

Lists

Anarcho-punk
Anarcho-punk
bands Communities Fictional characters Jewish anarchists Love & sex Musicians Organizations Periodicals Poets Russian anarchists Films

Related topics

Anti-capitalism Anti-corporatism Anti-consumerism Anti-fascism Anti-globalization Anti-statism Anti-war Autarchism Autonomism Communism Labour movement Left communism Libertarianism Libertarian socialism Libertarian marxism Marxism Situationist International Socialism Spontaneous order

Anarchism
Anarchism
portal Politics portal

v t e

Tucker said that he became an anarchist at the age of 18.[6] Tucker's contribution to American individualist anarchism was as much through his publishing as his own writing. Tucker was also the first to publish an English translation of Max Stirner's The Ego and Its Own – which Tucker claimed was his proudest accomplishment. Tucker also translated Mikhail Bakunin's book God and the State.[7] In the anarchist periodical Liberty, he published the original work of Stephen Pearl Andrews, Joshua K. Ingalls, Lysander Spooner, Auberon Herbert, Dyer Lum, Victor Yarros, and Lillian Harman (daughter of the free love anarchist Moses Harman), as well as his own writing. According to Frank Brooks, an historian of American individualist anarchism, it is easy to misunderstand Tucker's claim to socialism. Before Marxists established a hegemony over definitions of socialism, "the term socialism was a broad concept." Tucker, as well as most of the writers and readers of Liberty, understood socialism to refer to one or more of various theories aimed at solving "the labor problem" through radical changes in the capitalist economy. Descriptions of 'the problem', explanations of its causes, and proposed solutions (for example, abolition of private property, cooperatives, state-ownership, and so on) varied among socialist philosophies.[8] However, not all modern economists believe Marxists established a hegemony over definitions of socialism. As the modern economist Jim Stanford states:

But capitalism is not the only economic system which relies on markets. Pre-capitalist economies also had markets-where producers could sell excess supplies of agricultural goods or handicrafts, and where exotic commodities (like spices or fabrics) from far-off lands could be purchased. Most forms of socialism also rely heavily on markets to distribute end products and even, in some cases, to organize investment and production. So markets are not unique to capitalism, and there is nothing inherently capitalist about a market.[9]

Karl Marx
Karl Marx
acknowledged the theory of market socialism, though he strongly disagreed with the theory, especially the theory of Proudhon who happened to be an influence on Tucker's individualist anarchism.[10] According to James J. Martin, a historian on individualist anarchism, the individualist anarchists (including the views of Tucker and his support for the labor theory of value), made the individualist anarchists and their form of American mutualism an alternative to both capitalism and Marxism.[11] Tucker said socialism was the claim that "labor should be put in possession of its own,"[12] while holding that what "state socialism" and "anarchistic socialism" had in common was the labor theory of value.[13] However, "Instead of asserting, as did..." other "....anarchists, that common ownership was the key to eroding differences of economic power," and appealing to social solidarity, Tucker's individualist anarchism advocated distribution of property in an undistorted natural market, as a mediator of egoistic impulses and a source of social stability.[14] Tucker said:

the fact that one class of men are dependent for their living upon the sale of their labour, while another class of men are relieved of the necessity of labour by being legally privileged to sell something that is not labour. . . . And to such a state of things I am as much opposed as any one. But the minute you remove privilege. . . every man will be a labourer exchanging with fellow-labourers . . . What Anarchistic- Socialism
Socialism
aims to abolish is usury . . . it wants to deprive capital of its reward.[15]

Tucker first favored a natural rights philosophy, in which an individual had a right to own the fruits of his labor; then he abandoned it in favor of "egoism" (influenced by Max Stirner), in which he believed that only the "right of might" exists, until overridden by contract. He objected to all forms of communism, believing that even a stateless communist society must encroach upon the liberty of individuals.[16]

He denounced Marx as the representative of "the principle of authority which we live to combat." He thought Proudhon the superior theorist and the real champion of freedom. "Marx would nationalize the productive and distributive forces; Proudhon would individualize and associate them."[17]

Tucker connected his economic views which included his opposition to non-labor income in the form of profit, interest, and rent with those of Pierre Joseph Proudhon, Josiah Warren
Josiah Warren
and Karl Marx
Karl Marx
in the following form:

The economic principles of Modern Socialism
Socialism
are a logical deduction from the principle laid down by Adam Smith
Adam Smith
in the early chapters of his "Wealth of Nations," – namely, that labor is the true measure of price...Half a century or more after Smith enunciated the principle above stated, Socialism
Socialism
picked it up where he had dropped it, and in following it to its logical conclusions, made it the basis of a new economic philosophy...This seems to have been done independently by three different men, of three different nationalities, in three different languages: Josiah Warren, an American; Pierre J. Proudhon, a Frenchman; Karl Marx, a German Jew...That the work of this interesting trio should have been done so nearly simultaneously would seem to indicate that Socialism
Socialism
was in the air, and that the time was ripe and the conditions favorable for the appearance of this new school of thought. So far as priority of time is concerned, the credit seems to belong to Warren, the American, – a fact which should be noted by the stump orators who are so fond of declaiming against Socialism
Socialism
as an imported article. Benjamin Tucker. Individual Liberty[18]

Liberty
Liberty
(1881–1908)[edit] Main article: Liberty
Liberty
(1881–1908)

Liberty
Liberty
(1881–1908)

Liberty
Liberty
was a nineteenth-century anarchist periodical published in the United States
United States
by Benjamin Tucker, from August 1881 to April 1908. The periodical was instrumental in developing and formalizing the individualist anarchist philosophy through publishing essays and serving as a format for debate. Contributors included Benjamin Tucker, Lysander Spooner, Gertrude Kelly, Auberon Herbert, Dyer Lum, Joshua K. Ingalls, John Henry Mackay, Victor Yarros, Wordsworth Donisthorpe, James L. Walker, J. William Lloyd, Florence Finch Kelly, Voltairine de Cleyre, Steven T. Byington, John Beverley Robinson, Jo Labadie, Lillian Harman, and Henry Appleton. Included in its masthead is a quote from Pierre Proudhon saying that liberty is "Not the Daughter But the Mother of Order." The Four Monopolies[edit]

Part of a series on

Libertarian socialism

Political concepts

Anti-authoritarianism Anti-Leninism Anti-Stalinist left Anti-statism Classless society Consensus democracy Commune Decentralization Direct democracy Dual power Class struggle Egalitarian community Free association Free love Free school General strike Libertarian municipalism Libertarian possibilism Mutual aid Prefigurative politics Proletarian internationalism Refusal of work Social center Stateless society Squatting Ultra-leftism Wage slavery Workers' control Workers' council

Economics

Anarchist economics Anti-capitalism Anti-consumerism Cooperative Common ownership Common resources Cost the limit of price Decentralized planning Economic democracy Free store Gift economy Guilds Industrial democracy Really Really Free Market Social economy Social enterprise Socialization State capitalism Use value Worker cooperative

People

William Godwin Charles Fourier Pierre-Joseph Proudhon Mikhail Bakunin Louise Michel Peter Kropotkin Karl Marx William Morris Oscar Wilde Benjamin Tucker Errico Malatesta Leo Tolstoy Albert Parsons Lucy Parsons Francisco Ferrer Guardia Emma Goldman Alexander Berkman Leon Czolgosz Ricardo Flores Magón Rosa Luxemburg Karl Liebknecht Gustav Landauer Sacco and Vanzetti Rudolf Rocker Otto Rühle Antonie Pannekoek Buenaventura Durruti Diego Abad de Santillán Federica Montseny Nestor Makhno Stepan Maximovich Petrichenko Marinus van der Lubbe Sylvia Pankhurst Paul Mattick Wilhelm Reich Dorothy Day Albert Camus Jean-Paul Sartre Karl Korsch Herbert Marcuse Cornelius Castoriadis C. L. R. James Dorothy Thompson Raya Dunayevskaya Grace Lee Boggs Paul Goodman Colin Ward Chris Pallis Daniel Guérin Murray Bookchin Guy Debord Raoul Vaneigem Abbie Hoffman Antonio Negri Silvia Federici Félix Guattari John Holloway André Gorz Noam Chomsky Howard Zinn Gilles Dauvé Alfredo M. Bonanno David Graeber Subcomandante Marcos Yanis Varoufakis Abdullah Öcalan

Philosophies and tendencies

Anarchist tendencies

Anarchist communism Anarcho-pacifism Anarcho-syndicalism Christian anarchism Collectivist anarchism Egoist anarchism Individualist anarchism Insurrectionary anarchism Left-wing market anarchism Magonism Makhnovism Mutualism Participism Platformism Synthesis anarchism

Libertarian Marxist tendencies

Autonomism Communization Council communism Johnson-Forest Tendency Luxemburgism Situationist International

Other tendencies

Communalism Democratic Confederalism Fourierism Inclusive Democracy Neozapatismo

Significant events

Diggers Enragés Paris Commune Haymarket affair Assassination of William McKinley Strandzha Commune Russian Revolution Bavarian Soviet Republic German Revolution
Revolution
of 1918–1919 Biennio Rosso Ukrainian War of Independence Left-wing uprisings against the Bolsheviks
Left-wing uprisings against the Bolsheviks
(Kronstadt uprising) Escuela Moderna Mexican Revolution Reichstag fire Spanish Revolution 1953 East German uprising 1956 Hungarian Revolution May 1968 in France Prague Spring Left communism
Left communism
in China Hippie movement Autonomia Operaia Zapatista uprising 1999 Seattle WTO protests Argentinazo Occupy movement Kurdisk-Turkish conflict (2015 rebellion) Iran-PJAK conflict Rojava Revolution

Related topics

Anarchism Libertarianism Left-libertarianism Marxism Socialism

Anarchism
Anarchism
portal Socialism
Socialism
portal Libertarianism
Libertarianism
portal Philosophy portal Politics portal

v t e

Part of a series on

Socialism
Socialism
in the United States

History Utopian socialism

New Harmony Brook Farm Oneida Community Icarians Bishop Hill Commune

Progressive Era

St. Louis Commune 1912 Lawrence Textile Strike Labor unionisation Women's suffrage Haymarket affair May Day Green Corn Rebellion

Repression and persecution

Espionage Act of 1917 First Red Scare American Defense Society American Protective League Seattle General Strike Communist Party USA
Communist Party USA
and African Americans Communism
Communism
in the Labor Movement 1919–37 Communism
Communism
in the Labor Movement 1937–50 McCarthyism Smith Act / Smith Act
Smith Act
trials John Birch Society

Civil rights / anti-War movements

COINTELPRO New Left Great Society War on Poverty Poor People's Campaign Black Power movement

Active parties

American Party of Labor Black Riders Liberation Party Committees of Correspondence for Democracy and Socialism
Socialism
(CDCS) Communist Party USA Democratic Socialists of America Freedom Road Socialist Organization Freedom Socialist Party Industrial Workers of the World International Socialist Organization Legal Marijuana Now Party New Afrikan Black Panther Party New Students for a Democratic Society Party for Socialism
Socialism
and Liberation Peace and Freedom Party Progressive Labor Party Revolutionary Communist Party Socialist Action Socialist Alternative Socialist Equality Party Socialist Organizer Socialist Party Socialist Workers Party Spartacist League Workers World Party World Socialist Party of the United States

Defunct parties

American Labor Party American Workers Party Black Panther Party Communist League of America Communist Workers' Party Democratic Socialist Federation Democratic Socialist Organizing Committee Farmer–Labor Party Maoist Internationalist Movement New American Movement Proletarian Party of America Puerto Rican Socialist Party Social Democracy of America Social Democratic Federation Social Democratic Party of America Social Democrats, USA Socialist Labor Party of America Socialist Party of America Students for a Democratic Society Weather Underground White Panther Party Workers Party of the United States Youth International Party

Literature

The Jungle Appeal to Reason International Socialist Review Looking Backward The Other America Daily Worker Monthly Review Voluntary Socialism Monopoly Capital

Related topics

American Left Anarchism Anarchism
Anarchism
in the United States Socialism Utopian socialism Scientific socialism Marxism Marxism–Leninism Labor history Labor unions Libertarian socialism Labor laws Minimum wage

Socialism
Socialism
portal United States
United States
portal

v t e

Tucker argued that the poor condition of American workers resulted from four legal monopolies based in authority:

the money monopoly the land monopoly tariffs patents

His focus, for several decades, became the state's economic control of how trade could take place, and what currency counted as legitimate. He saw interest and profit as a form of exploitation, made possible by the banking monopoly, which was in turn maintained through coercion and invasion. Tucker called any such interest and profit "usury" and he saw it as the basis of the oppression of the workers. In his words,

interest is theft, Rent Robbery, and Profit Only Another Name for Plunder.[19]

Tucker believed that usury was immoral; however, he upheld the right of all people to engage in immoral contracts.

Liberty, therefore, must defend the right of individuals to make contracts involving usury, rum, marriage, prostitution, and many other things which are believed to be wrong in principle and opposed to human well-being. The right to do wrong involves the essence of all rights.[20]

He asserted that anarchism would become meaningless unless:

it includes the liberty of the individual to control his product or whatever his product has brought him through exchange in a free market – that is, private property.

Land monopoly[edit] He acknowledged that "anything is a product upon which human labor has been expended," but would not recognize full property rights to labored-upon land:

It should be noted, however, that in the case of land, or of any other material the supply of which is so limited that all cannot hold it in unlimited quantities, Anarchism
Anarchism
undertakes to protect no titles except such as are based upon actual occupancy and use.[21]

Tucker opposed granting title to land that was not in use; he argued that an individual should use land continually, in order to retain exclusive right to it. He believed that if this practice were not followed, there was a 'land monopoly'. Money and banking monopoly[edit] Tucker also opposed state protection of the 'banking monopoly' – the requirement that one must obtain a charter to engage in the business of banking. He hoped to raise wages by deregulating the banking industry, reasoning that competition in banking would drive down interest rates and stimulate enterprise. Tucker believed this would decrease the proportion of individuals seeking employment, and wages would be driven up by competing employers. "Thus, the same blow that strikes interest down will send wages up."[22] He did not oppose individuals being employed by others, but due to his interpretation of the labor theory of value, he believed that in the present economy individuals do not receive a wage that fully compensates them for their labor. He wrote that, if the four "monopolies" were ended,

it will make no difference whether men work for themselves, or are employed, or employ others. In any case they can get nothing but that wages for their labor which free competition determines.[23]

Tariffs and patents[edit] Tucker opposed protectionism, believing that tariffs caused high prices, by preventing national producers from having to compete with foreign competitors. He believed that free trade would help keep prices low and therefore would assist laborers in receiving their "natural wage". Tucker did not believe in intellectual property rights in the form of patents, on the grounds that patents and copyrights protect something which cannot rightfully be held as property. He wrote that the basis for property is "the fact that it is impossible in the nature of things for concrete objects to be used in different places at the same time."[24] Property in concrete things is "socially necessary":

since successful society rests on individual initiative, [it is necessary] to protect the individual creator in the use of his concrete creations by forbidding others to use them without his consent.

Because ideas are not concrete things, they should not be held and protected as property. Ideas can be used in different places at the same time, and so their use should not be restricted by patents.[25] This was a source of conflict with the philosophy of fellow individualist Lysander Spooner, who saw ideas as the product of "intellectual labor" and therefore private property.[26] Yarros on Tucker[edit] According to Victor Yarros:

He [Tucker] opposed savagely any and all reform movements that had paternalistic aims, and looked to the state for aid and fulfillment...For the same reason, consistent, unrelenting opposition to compulsion, he combated "populism," "greenbackism," the single-tax movement, and all forms of socialism and communism. He denounced and exposed Johann Most, the editor of Freiheit, the anarchist-communist organ. The end, he declared, could never justify the means, if the means were intrinsically immoral – and force, by whomsoever used, was immoral except as a means of preventing or punishing aggression.[27]

Attitude towards unions[edit] Tucker rejected the legislative programs of labor unions, laws imposing a short day, minimum wage laws, forcing businesses to provide insurance to employees, and compulsory pension systems.[27] He believed instead that strikes should be organized by free workers rather than by bureaucratic union officials and organizations. He argued,

strikes, whenever and wherever inaugurated, deserve encouragement from all the friends of labour. . . They show that people are beginning to know their rights, and knowing, dare to maintain them.[28]

and furthermore,

as an awakening agent, as an agitating force, the beneficent influence of a strike is immeasurable. . . with our present economic system almost every strike is just. For what is justice in production and distribution? That labour, which creates all, shall have all.[29]

Anarchist society[edit] Tucker envisioned an individualist anarchist society as

each man reaping the fruits of his labour and no man able to live in idleness on an income from capital....become[ing] a great hive of Anarchistic workers, prosperous and free individuals [combining] to carry on their production and distribution on the cost principle.[30]

rather than a bureaucratic organization of workers organized into rank and file unions. However, he did hold a genuine appreciation for labor unions (which he called "trades-union socialism"), and saw it as "an intelligent and self-governing socialism" saying, "[they] promise the coming substitution of industrial socialism for usurping legislative mobism."[31] In Tucker's Individualist Anarchism, governments would exist consisting of any belief, and in any shape, or form but the governments would be supported by voluntary taxation and those who chose not to pay the taxes would not get the benefits or protection of the voluntary government. Historian James Martin states:

The abolition of compulsory taxation would mean the abolition of the state as well, Tucker asserted, and the form of society succeeding it would be on the line of a voluntary defensive institution... There were two methods of government...The other was the anarchist method of "leadership", inducing the individual to the "goal of an ideal civilization" through persuasion and "attraction"...Two aims of anarchist activity, the abolition of compulsory taxation and the abolition of legally-protected money and land monopolies, form the main theme of his critical writing... [32]

Private defense forces[edit] Tucker did not have a utopian vision of anarchy, where individuals would not coerce others.[27] He advocated that liberty and property be defended by private institutions. Opposing the monopoly of the state in providing security, he advocated a free market of competing defense providers, saying "defense is a service like any other service; ... it is labor both useful and desired, and therefore an economic commodity, subject to the law of supply and demand."[33] He said that anarchism

does not exclude prisons, officials, military, or other symbols of force. It merely demands that non-invasive men shall not be made the victims of such force. Anarchism
Anarchism
is not the reign of love, but the reign of justice. It does not signify the abolition of force-symbols but the application of force to real invaders.[34]

Tucker expressed that the market-based providers of security would offer protection of land that was being used, and would not offer assistance to those attempting to collect rent:

"The land for the people" . . . means the protection by . . . voluntary associations for the maintenance of justice . . . of all people who desire to cultivate land in possession of whatever land they personally cultivate . . . and the positive refusal of the protecting power to lend its aid to the collection of any rent, whatsoever.[35]

Embrace of "egoism"[edit]

Part of a series on

Individualism

Topics and concepts

Autonomy Civil liberties Do it yourself Eremitism Free love Freethought Human rights Individual Individual rights Individual reclamation Individuation Laissez-faire Libertinism Liberty Methodological individualism Negative liberty Personal property Positive liberty Private property Self-actualization Self-ownership Self reliance Subjectivity

Thinkers

Antiphon Aristippus Aristotle Émile Armand Albert Camus Diogenes of Sinope Ralph Waldo Emerson Epicurus William Godwin Emma Goldman Friedrich Hayek Karl Hess Miguel Giménez Igualada Thomas Jefferson Laozi Albert Libertad John Locke Hipparchia of Maroneia H. L. Mencken John Stuart Mill Ludwig von Mises Michel de Montaigne Friedrich Nietzsche Renzo Novatore Robert Nozick Michel Onfray Georges Palante Horst Matthai Quelle Ayn Rand Murray Rothbard Han Ryner Marquis de Sade Arthur Schopenhauer Adam Smith Herbert Spencer Lysander Spooner Max Stirner Henry David Thoreau Benjamin Tucker James L. Walker Josiah Warren Oscar Wilde Zeno Yang Zhu

Philosophies

Anarchism Anarcho-capitalism Classical liberalism Egoist anarchism Ethical egoism Existentialism Hedonism Humanism Individualist anarchism Individualist feminism

Equity feminism Liberal feminism

Left-libertarianism Left-wing market anarchism Liberalism Libertarianism Libertarian socialism Minarchism Mutualism Objectivism Right libertarianism Social anarchism Voluntaryism

Principal concerns

Anti-individualism Authoritarianism Collectivism Conformity Dogmatism Group rights Herd mentality Indoctrination Mass society Mobbing Social engineering Statism Tyranny Tyranny
Tyranny
of the majority Theocracy Totalitarianism

v t e

Tucker abandoned natural rights positions and converted to Max Stirner's Egoist anarchism. Rejecting the idea of moral rights, Tucker said that there were only two rights, "the right of might" and "the right of contract." He also said, after converting to Egoist individualism, "In times past...it was my habit to talk glibly of the right of man to land. It was a bad habit, and I long ago sloughed it off....Man's only right to land is his might over it."[36] In adopting Stirnerite egoism (1886), Tucker rejected natural rights which had long been considered the foundation of libertarianism. This rejection galvanized the movement into fierce debates, with the natural rights proponents accusing the egoists of destroying libertarianism itself. So bitter was the conflict that a number of natural rights proponents withdrew from the pages of Liberty
Liberty
in protest even though they had hitherto been among its frequent contributors. Thereafter, Liberty
Liberty
championed egoism although its general content did not change significantly.[37] This led to a split in American Individualism
Individualism
between the growing number of Egoists and the contemporary Spoonerian "Natural Lawyers". Tucker came to hold the position that no rights exist until they are created by contract. This led him to controversial positions such as claiming that infants had no rights and were the property of their parents, because they did not have the ability to contract. He said that a person, who physically tries to stop a mother from throwing her "baby into the fire", should be punished for violating her property rights. He said that children would shed their status as property, when they became old enough to contract "to buy or sell a house" for example, noting that the precocity varies by age and would be determined by a jury in the case of a complaint.[38] He also came to believe that aggression towards others was justifiable if doing so led to a greater decrease in "aggregate pain" than refraining from doing so. He said:

the ultimate end of human endeavor is the minimum of pain. We aim to decrease invasion only because, as a rule, invasion increases the total of pain (meaning, of course, pain suffered by the ego, whether directly or through sympathy with others). But it is precisely my contention that this rule, despite the immense importance which I place upon it, is not absolute; that, on the contrary, there are exceptional cases where invasion – that is, coercion of the non-invasive – lessens the aggregate pain. Therefore coercion of the non-invasive, when justifiable at all, is to be justified on the ground that it secures, not a minimum of invasion, but a minimum of pain. . . . [T]o me [it is] axiomatic – that the ultimate end is the minimum of pain[39]

Tucker now said that there were only two rights, "the right of might" and "the right of contract." He also said, after converting to Egoist individualism, that ownership in land is legitimately transferred through force unless contracted otherwise. In 1892, he said "In times past...it was my habit to talk glibly of the right of man to land. It was a bad habit, and I long ago sloughed it off. Man's only right to land is his might over it. If his neighbor is mightier than he and takes the land from him, then the land is his neighbor's, until the latter is dispossessed by one mightier still."[40] However, he said he believed that individuals would come to the realization that "equal liberty" and "occupancy and use" doctrines were "generally trustworthy guiding principle of action," and, as a result, they would likely find it in their interests to contract with each other to refrain from infringing upon equal liberty and from protecting land that was not in use.[41] Though he believed that non-invasion, and "occupancy and use as the title to land" were general rules that people would find in their own interests to create through contract, he said that these rules "must be sometimes trodden underfoot."[42] Later life[edit] In 1906, he opened Tucker's Unique Book Shop in New York City – promoting "Egoism in Philosophy, Anarchism
Anarchism
in Politics, Iconoclasm in Art". In 1908, a fire destroyed Tucker's uninsured printing equipment and his 30-year stock of books and pamphlets. Tucker's lover, Pearl Johnson – 25 years his junior – was pregnant with their daughter, Oriole Tucker. Six weeks after Oriole's birth, Tucker closed both Liberty
Liberty
and the book shop and retired with his family to France. In 1913, he came out of retirement for two years to contribute articles and letters to The New Freewoman which he called "the most important publication in existence." Later Tucker became much more pessimistic about the prospects for anarchism. In 1926, Vanguard Press published a selection of his writings entitled Individual Liberty, in which Tucker added a postscript[43] to "State Socialism
Socialism
and Anarchism",[44] which stated

Forty years ago, when the foregoing essay was written, the denial of competition had not yet effected the enormous concentration of wealth that now so gravely threatens social order. It was not yet too late to stem the current of accumulation by a reversal of the policy of monopoly. The Anarchistic remedy was still applicable.

But, Tucker argued,

Today the way is not so clear. The four monopolies, unhindered, have made possible the modern development of the trust, and the trust is now a monster which I fear, even the freest banking, could it be instituted, would be unable to destroy. ... If this be true, then monopoly, which can be controlled permanently only for economic forces, has passed for the moment beyond their reach, and must be grappled with for a time solely by forces political or revolutionary. Until measures of forcible confiscation, through the State or in defiance of it, shall have abolished the concentrations that monopoly has created, the economic solution proposed by Anarchism
Anarchism
and outlined in the forgoing pages – and there is no other solution... [It] will remain a thing to be taught to the rising generation, that conditions may be favorable to its application after the great leveling. But education is a slow process, and may not come too quickly. Anarchists who endeavor to hasten it by joining in the propaganda of State Socialism
Socialism
or revolution make a sad mistake indeed. They help to so force the march of events that the people will not have time to find out, by the study of their experience, that their troubles have been due to the rejection of competition.

By 1930, Tucker had concluded that centralization and advancing technology had doomed both anarchy and civilization.

The matter of my famous 'Postscript' now sinks into insignificance; the insurmountable obstacle to the realization of Anarchy
Anarchy
is no longer the power of the trusts, but the indisputable fact that our civilization is in its death throes. We may last a couple of centuries yet; on the other hand, a decade may precipitate our finish. ... The dark ages sure enough. The Monster, Mechanism, is devouring mankind.[45]

According to James Martin, when referring to the world scene of the mid-1930s in private correspondence, Tucker wrote: " Capitalism
Capitalism
is at least tolerable, which cannot be said of Socialism
Socialism
or Communism" and went on to observe that, "under any of these regimes a sufficiently shrewd man can feather his nest.".[46] Susan Love Brown claims that this unpublished, private letter, which does not distinguish between the anarchist socialism Tucker advocated and the state socialism he criticized, served in "providing the shift further illuminated in the 1970s by anarcho-capitalists."[47] However according to the editors of the 1970 Edition of Individualist Anarchist historian James J. Martin's book Men Against the State, the editors state on the back cover they believed a "...new generation has prompted the reissuance of this book..." [48] pointing to renewed interest in the views of Tucker and the other Individualst Anarchists and their market socialism [49] rather than capitalism or anarcho-capitalism. Tucker died in Monaco
Monaco
in 1939, in the company of his family. His daughter, Oriole, reported,

Father's attitude towards communism never changed one whit, nor about religion.... In his last months he called in the French housekeeper. 'I want her,' he said, 'to be a witness that on my death bed I'm not recanting. I do not believe in God![50]

In popular culture[edit] In the alternate history novel The Probability Broach by L. Neil Smith, as part of the North American Confederacy Series in which the United States
United States
becomes a libertarian state after a successful Whiskey Rebellion and the overthrowing and execution of George Washington
George Washington
by firing squad for treason in 1794, Tucker served as the 17th President of the North American Confederacy from 1892 to 1912. References[edit]

^ David Hart. "Gustave De Molinari And The Anti-Statist Liberal Tradition". The Journal of Libertarian Studies, Vol. VI, No. 1 (Winter 1982), p. 87 (online; PDF p. 5): "Tucker was definitely aware of Molinari's work and at least one of Molinari's books was reviewed in Tucker's magazine. He shared Molinari's view that the production of security was an economic commodity which could be better supplied by the free and unhampered market, thus going beyond the criticism of Herbert and Spencer and, arguing with Molinari, that the market could offer a positive and practical alternative to state monopoly defense." ^ Tucker translated Mikhail Bakunin's book God and the State
God and the State
Mikhail Bakunin at marxists.org ^ "within the strictly anarchist world we find some theorists like Ricardo Mella, who, due to his knowledge of the English language, knows deeply the work of (Benjamin) Tucker and that of the north American individualists, especially by reading regularly the British magazine Freedom and the north American ones The Alarm (Chicago) and the tuckerian Liberty
Liberty
(Boston)…Uncomfortable within the polemics between collectivists and libertarian communists, the Galician anarchist tries to integrate the different ideological currents under the proposal of Tarrida del Mármol of an anarchism without adjectives." Diez, X. (2007). El anarquismo individualista en España (1923–1938). Virus. p. 92 ^ McCarthy, Daniel (2010-01-01) A Fistful of Dynamite, The American Conservative ^ McElroy, Wendy (Winter 1998). "Benjamin Tucker, Liberty, and Individualist Anarchism" (PDF). The Independent Review. II (3): 421.  ^ Symes, Lillian and Clement, Travers. Rebel America: The Story of Social Revolt in the United States. Harper & Brothers Publishers. 1934. p. 156 ^ at marxists.org ^ Brooks, Frank H. 1994. The Individualist Anarchists: An Anthology of Liberty
Liberty
(1881–1908). Transaction Publishers. p. 75. ^ Stanford, Jim. Economics for Everyone: A Short Guide to the Economics of Capitalism. Ann Arbor: MI., Pluto Press. 2008. p. 36. ^ "Communist Manifesto" by Karl Marx ^ James J. Martin, Men Against the State. Ralph Myles Publisher Inc. 1970. p. viii, ix, 209. ^ Tucker, Benjamin. "State Socialism
Socialism
and Anarchism," ¶ 1. ^ Brown, Susan Love. 1997. "The Free Market as Salvation from Government". In Meanings of the Market: The Free Market in Western Culture. Berg Publishers. p. 107. ^ Freeden, Michael. 1996. Ideologies and Political Theory: A Conceptual Approach. Oxford University Press. p. 276. ^ [Instead of a Book, p. 404] ^ Madison, Charles A. Anarchism
Anarchism
in the United States. Journal of the History of Ideas, Vol 6, No 1, January 1945, p. 53. ^ Richman, Sheldon, Libertarian Left, The American Conservative
The American Conservative
(March 2011) ^ Individual Liberty
Liberty
by Benjamin Tucker ^ Martin Blatt, Benjamin R. Tucker and the Champions of Liberty. Coughlin, Hamilton and Sullivan (eds.), p. 29 ^ Benjamin R. Tucker, "Right and Individual Rights," Liberty
Liberty
I (January 7, 1882): p. 3. ^ Tucker, Benjamin, "Instead of a Book", p. 61, footnote. ^ [1] Libertarian Heritage No. 23. ISSN 0959-566X ISBN 1-85637-549-8, Libertarian Alliance, 2002. ^ Tucker, Benjamin. "Solutions of the Labor Problem," in Instead of a Book, p. 475. ^ "The Attitude of Anarchism
Anarchism
toward Industrial Combinations" ^ Tucker, Benjamin: The Attitude of Anarchism
Anarchism
toward Industrial Combinations ^ Spooner, Lysander. The Law of Intellectual Property: or an essay on the right of authors and inventors to a perpetual property in their ideas. Archived May 24, 2014, at the Wayback Machine., Chapter 1, Section VI. ^ a b c Victor Yarros (1936). "Philosophical Anarchism: Its Rise, Decline, and Eclipse". The American Journal of Sociology. 41 (4): 470–83. doi:10.1086/217188.  ^ Benjamin Tucker, Liberty, 15/4/1881 ^ Benjamin Tucker, Liberty, #19, 1882 ^ The Individualist Anarchists, p. 276 ^ The Individualist Anarchists, pp. 283–284 ^ Martin, James. Men Against The State. Ralph Myles Publisher, Inc. Colorado Springs. 1970. p. 216, 218. ^ "On Picket Duty." Liberty. July 30, 1887; 4, 26. p4. ^ Tucker, Benjamin. Liberty
Liberty
October 19, 1891. ^ quoted by Martin Blatt, Benjamin R. Tucker and the Champions of Liberty, Coughlin, Hamilton and Sullivan (eds.), p. 299 ^ Tucker, Instead of a Book, p. 350 ^ Wendy Mcelroy. "Benjamin Tucker, Individualism, & Liberty: Not the Daughter but the Mother of Order" ^ McElroy, Wendy. 2003. The Debates of Liberty. Lexington Books. pp. 77–79 ^ "Land Tenure Again." Liberty. October 19, 1895; 11, 12; p. 3. ^ Benjamin R. Tucker, "Response to 'Rights,' by William Hansen," Liberty, December 31, 1892; pp. 9, 18; p. 1 ^ Benjamin R. Tucker, "The Two Conceptions of Equal Freedom," Liberty, April 6, 1895; 10, 24; p. 4 ^ Tucker, "Land Tenure Again" ^ a postscript ^ "State Socialism
Socialism
and Anarchism" ^ Letter to Clarence Lee Swartz, July 22, 1930. In Joseph Ishill (ed.), Free Vistas: A Libertarian Outlook on Life and Letters, II, 300–301. Quoted in James J. Martin, Men Against the State, 1953:260. ^ James J. Martin, Men Against the State, 1970:275, quoting from the Baskette Collection (1933–1935) ^ Brown, Susan L., The Free Market as Salvation from Government, Meanings of the Market: The Free Market in Western Culture, p. 108 ^ James J. Martin, Men Against the State, 1970: description on back cover ^ James J. Martin, Men Against the State, 1970: Introduction ix, ^ Paul Avrich (1996). "Oriole Tucker Riché". Anarchist Voices. Princeton University Press. p. 11. ISBN 0-691-04494-5. 

Further reading[edit]

Steelman, Aaron (2008). "Tucker, Benjamin R. (1854–1939)". In Hamowy, Ronald. The Encyclopedia of Libertarianism. Thousand Oaks, CA: SAGE; Cato Institute. pp. 513–14. doi:10.4135/9781412965811.n313. ISBN 978-1-4129-6580-4. LCCN 2008009151. OCLC 750831024. 

External links[edit]

Wikimedia Commons has media related to Benjamin Tucker.

Wikiquote has quotations related to: Benjamin Tucker

Wikisource
Wikisource
has original works written by or about: Benjamin Tucker

Instead of a Book, by a Man Too Busy to Write One (1893, 1897) Travelling in Liberty: a complete online archive of Tucker's journal Liberty
Liberty
(1881–1908) Several works by Tucker at Anarchy
Anarchy
Archives State Socialism
Socialism
and Anarchism. How far they agree and wherein they differ (1886) Liberty
Liberty
and Taxation From the magazine Liberty
Liberty
1881–1908 Individual Liberty
Liberty
(1926); collection of articles Tucker on Property, Communism
Communism
and Socialism BlackCrayon.com: People: Benjamin Tucker Benjamin Tucker
Benjamin Tucker
Anarchy
Anarchy
Archives Benjamin Tucker, Liberty, and Individualist Anarchism
Anarchism
by Wendy McElroy Benjamin Ricketson Tucker from "CLASSicalLiberalism" archive Benjamin Tucker
Benjamin Tucker
and His Periodical, Liberty
Liberty
by Carl Watner Memories of Benjamin Tucker
Benjamin Tucker
by J. William Lloyd (1935) An Interview With Oriole Tucker Tucker's daughter reveals biographical information, by Paul Avrich Benjamin R Tucker & the Champions of Liberty
Liberty
– A Centenary Anthology Edited by Michael E. Coughlin, Charles H. Hamilton and Mark A. Sullivan Works by Benjamin Tucker
Benjamin Tucker
at Project Gutenberg Works by or about Benjamin Tucker
Benjamin Tucker
at Internet Archive Works by Benjamin Tucker
Benjamin Tucker
at LibriVox
LibriVox
(public domain audiobooks) Benjamin Tucker
Benjamin Tucker
at Goodreads Benjamin Tucker
Benjamin Tucker
at Find a Grave "Benjamin Tucker: American Mutualist" By Evans Press (2017) "Benjamin Tucker: American Mutualist Part 2: A Brief Introduction to the Freedoms in the Individualist Society" by Nicholas Evans (2017) "Benjamin Tucker: American Mutualist Part 3: Mutual Banking
Banking
and Part 4: Final Conclusion" By Nicholas Evans 2017 "Benjamin Tucker: Individualist Libertarian Market Socialist" By Nicholas Evans 2017

Authority control

WorldCat Identities VIAF: 67365108 LCCN: n50012630 ISNI: 0000 0000 8254 8037 GND: 123100003 SUDOC: 030604508 BNF: cb12198626r (data) NLA: 35557360 NKC: vse2010585

.